These examples are sufficient to illustrate the organization and working of the municipal machine.It must not be imagined by the reader that these cities alone, and a few others made notorious by the magazine muck-rakers, are the only American cities that have developed oligarchies.In truth, not a single American city, great or small, has entirely escaped, for a greater or lesser period, the sway of a coterie of politicians.It has not always been a corrupt sway; but it has rarely, if ever, given efficient administration.
Happily there are not wanting signs that the general conditions which have fostered the Ring are disappearing.The period of reform set in about 1890, when people began to be interested in the study of municipal government.It was not long afterwards that the first authoritative books on the subject appeared.Then colleges began to give courses in municipal government; editors began to realize the public's concern in local questions and to discuss neighborhood politics as well as national politics.By 1900 a new era broke--the era of the Grand Jury.Nothing so hopeful in local politics had occurred in our history as the disclosures which followed.They provoked the residuum of conscience in the citizenry and the determination that honesty should rule in public business and politics as well as in private transactions.The Grand Jury inquisitions, however, demonstrated clearly that the criminal law was no remedy for municipal misrule.The great majority of floaters and illegal voters who were indicted never faced a trial jury.The results of the prosecutions for bribery and grosser political crimes were scarcely more encouraging.It is true that one Abe Ruef in a California penitentiary is worth untold sermons, editorials, and platform admonitions, and serves as a potent warning to all public malefactors.Yet the example is soon forgotten; and the people return to their former political habits.
But out of this decade of gang-hunting and its impressive experiences with the shortcomings of our criminal laws came the new municipal era which we have now fully entered, the era of enlightened administration.This new era calls for a reconstruction of the city government.Its principal feature is the rapid spread of the Galveston or Commission form of government and of its modification, the City Manager plan, the aim of which is to centralize governmental authority and to entice able men into municipal office.And there are many other manifestations of the new civic spirit.The mesmeric influence of national party names in civic politics is waning; the rise of home rule for the city is severing the unholy alliance between the legislature and the local Ring; the power to grant franchises is being taken away from legislative bodies and placed directly with the people; nominations are passing out of the hands of cliques and are being made the gift of the voters through petitions and primaries; efficient reforms in the taxing and budgetary machinery have been instituted, and the development of the merit system in the civil service is creating a class of municipal experts beyond the reach of political gangsters.
There have sprung up all sorts of collateral organizations to help the officials: societies for municipal research, municipal reference libraries, citizens' unions, municipal leagues, and municipal parties.These are further supplemented by organizations which indirectly add to the momentum of practical, enlightened municipal sentiment: boards of commerce, associations of business and professional men of every variety, women's clubs, men's clubs, children's clubs, recreation clubs, social clubs, every one with its own peculiar vigilance upon some corner of the city's affairs.So every important city is guarded by a network of voluntary organizations.
All these changes in city government, in municipal laws and political mechanisms, and in the people's attitude toward their cities, have tended to dignify municipal service.The city job has been lifted to a higher plane.Lord Rosebery, the brilliant chairman of the first London County Council, the governing body of the world's largest city, said many years ago: "I wish that my voice could extend to every municipality in the kingdom, and impress upon every man, however high his position, however great his wealth, however consummate his talents may be, the importance and nobility of municipal work." It is such a spirit as this that has made the government of Glasgow a model of democratic efficiency; and it is the beginnings of this spirit that the municipal historian finds developing in the last twenty years of American life.It is indeed difficult to see how our cities can slip back again into the clutches of bosses and rings and repeat the shameful history of the last decades of the nineteenth century.
