登陆注册
15448000000011

第11章 PART II(2)

The right of the poor to live by labour, affirmed as unhesitatingly as if it were a self-evident proposition beyond the possibility of dispute, is explained to mean not merely the right so to live if they can themselves find the means, but to have the means supplied by others if they cannot themselves obtain them, and to have them supplied, nominally by society at large, but really by the richer portion of it, the rich alone being in a position to furnish what is required. But right on the one side necessarily implies corresponding obligation on the other; and how can society, or how can the rich, have incurred the obligation of maintaining in the world those whom they were in no degree instrumental in bringing into it? Only, if at all, in one or other of two ways. Either mankind were placed in possession of the earth which they inhabit on condition, expressed or implied, that the wants of all the earth's human inhabitants should be provided for from its produce; or part of those inhabitants have, by some communal act or institution of the whole body, been dispossessed of the means of providing for themselves. But in the first of these hypotheses, in order that the supposed condition should be equitable, it would be necessary that the earth should be capable of producing enough for the wants of whatever number of inhabitants might obtain footing upon it; whereas it is demonstrable that population would infallibly everywhere speedily outrun subsistence, if the earth's produce were freely accessible to all who had need. Of the other supposition, it is to be remarked that the only institution that has ever been accused of producing the alleged effect is the institution of property; and very slight advocacy will suffice to absolve an institution from the charge of depriving people of that which, but for itself, could not have existed. Let it be admitted that the earth was bestowed by the Creator, not on any privileged class or classes, but on all mankind, and on all successive generations of men, so that no one generation can have more than a life interest in the soil, or be entitled to alienate the birthright of succeeding generations. Let this be admitted, and the admission is surely large enough to satisfy the most uncompromising champion of the natural rights of man. Still it is certain that those rights, if fully exercised, must inevitably have proved themselves to be so far worse than worthless, as to have prevented any but a very minute fraction of the existing number of claimants from being born to claim them. The earth, if unappropriated, must also have remained untilled, and consequently comparatively unproductive.

Anything like the world's actual population could not possibly have been in existence, nor, if it had been, would a whole year's growth of the earth's natural produce have sufficed for the subsistence of the earth's inhabitants during a single day. The utmost of which the poor have been dispossessed by the institution of property is their fair proportion of what the earth could have produced if it had remained unappropriated. Compensation for this is the utmost which is due to them from society, and the debt is obviously so infinitesimally small, that the crumbs which habitually fall from the tables of the rich are amply sufficient to pay it.

If these things be so, a strict debtor and creditor account between rich and poor would show no balance against the former. Society cannot properly be said to owe anything to the poor beyond what it is constantly and regularly paying. It is not bound in equity, whatever it may be in charity, to find food for the hungry because they are in need, nor to find occupation for the unemployed because they are out of work. By withholding aid, it is not guilty of the smallest injustice. For injustice implies violation of a right; and not only can there be no breach of right without disregard of a corresponding obligation, but that only can be a right the breach or denial of which constitutes a wrong. But wrong is committed only when some good which is due is withheld, or when some evil which is not due is inflicted. Applying this test, we shall find that the poor, as such, have no unliquidated claim against the rich. The latter are doing them no wrong, are guilty of no injustice towards them in merely abstaining from paying a debt which, whether due to the poor or not, is, at any rate, not due to them from the rich. It was not the rich who placed the poor on the earth, and it is not the rich who owe them the means of living here.

How far the poor may be forgiven for complaining, as of a grievance, of having been placed here without adequate means of living, may possibly be a question for the theologian. But the political economist may fairly content himself with showing that the grievance is, at any rate, not one with which they can reproach any of their fellow-creatures, except their own parents. No other portion of society was a party to the transaction, and no other portion can justly be responsible for its consequences. (8) (Pp. 91-94.)

It is unnecessary to quote the application of these principles to the particular case of contracts for labour.

同类推荐
热门推荐
  • 极品妖孽

    极品妖孽

    不把九天拉下马,千年修道也枉然。当故事的主角“易林”飞升仙界以后,他曾说过这样的一句话:广寒宫嫦娥的闺房,迟早会成为老子睡觉的地方!(那么,就让我们一同见证妖孽的修真之旅吧。)
  • 男宠别跑:傲娇小姐要倒追

    男宠别跑:傲娇小姐要倒追

    咖啡店的初遇,激起的是她情窦的初开。她,身价万千的凌家大小姐,自从与他相遇以来,每天就想着怎么收了这只处处惹桃花的高冷男。他,叶家遗留在外多年的孩子,自从与她相遇以来,每天就想着怎么躲傲娇千金对他的恋爱追击。“小子,本小姐看上你了,做我的男宠吧。”第一次见面,她就在他身上打上了标签,豪放的对她姐妹宣言要追到这只咖啡店打工的服务生。她自作主张的把他调到自己的贵族学院又大庭广众之下强吻他,这样就算了,就这自大的凌大小姐竟是个男女通吃的娃,这可让他够受罪的。怎么追个人就那么难说好的女追男隔层纱呢,这分明就是隔着条鸿沟啊!(看傲娇LOLI狂追高冷男,分分钟教会你怎么玩倒追/大笑)
  • 石璞质禅师语录

    石璞质禅师语录

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 马利隔壁的女神

    马利隔壁的女神

    马利侦探所开业咯,倒霉的人生,前胸贴后背的钱包背后隐藏着怎样的故事?
  • 封魔道祖

    封魔道祖

    在当世,我要力压群雄,成为最强之人,要所谓的天才跪倒在我的脚下。至于老婆,不是漂亮美女我不收。身世虽然是迷,但也不能影响我纵横天下的心情。带着神秘玉佩,白阳炫开始了他热血的生涯!
  • 朝有青花

    朝有青花

    一个都市,千百人,千姿百态,总有那么一些事,一些人,在默默的发生
  • 校草老公太腹黑

    校草老公太腹黑

    他,很幸运,一见钟情的她竟然和他有婚姻关系,就算她在讨厌他,他也不着急,只要一个小小的红本本,她还是他的。她,讨厌父母的婚姻包办政策,这都二十一世纪了好吗?更让她气愤的,男方竟然是她们学校的校草,爸妈这不是想让全校女同学的口水淹死她的节奏吗?
  • 梦域之灵

    梦域之灵

    没看过多少小说,各个方面的纯新人,也许写的不好,但绝对不会和你看过的任何小说雷同。本文讲述的是一个普通大学生的梦域之旅,期间有各式各样的能力、奇遇以及男女主角的感情纠葛。
  • 非科学调查社

    非科学调查社

    刘小渣儿时有个梦想,想用科学的方法来解释那些超自然的事件,在大学里他很快找到了志同道和的人,他们成立‘非科学调查社团’,他们调查和搜索一件又一件的超自然现象,随着调查的深入,科学是否能帮助他们解释一切,让他们越来越理性,还是一件又一件超自然事件,让他们失去了理性......
  • 宠溺到底:独宠小娇妻

    宠溺到底:独宠小娇妻

    某女轻轻的走到顾默宸身边:“嘿嘿,我要出去吃饭。”顾默宸放下手中的东西看着这个磨人的小丫头:“和谁?男的女的?”“当然是男的喽!”顾默宸轻挑眉:“男的?不准去!”“为什么?你凭什么不让我去?你是我什么人啊?”顾默宸一步步走到这个小丫头的面前:“你说呢?嗯?你说我是你什么人?”“我,,,我不知道。”“不知道?那我好好的教教你。”就这样,米清儿就被“狠狠”的调教了一番。